The PAD challenge prompt for today is to write a Glosa poem, a Spanish form that works as well in the English language as in Spanish. Glosas open with a quatrain from another poet, each line containing an epigram, followed by four ten-line stanzas terminating with the lines of the initial passage in consecutive order. The sixth and ninth lines should rhyme with the borrowed tenth. My opening quatrain is the final four lines of William Shakespeare’s Sonnet 76
So all my best is dressing old words new,
Spending again what is already spent:
For as the sun is daily new and old,
So is my love still telling what is told.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
To write good poetry
is near impossible
without a knowledge
of form and metre –
in isolation, not enough
without example as a cue.
Read and read
until you’re filled
with beauty turned askew
so all my best is dressing old words new.
Fumbling in a fog
the poet searched
for something new to write,
disentangling his store
of the master’s prosody,
quotations already lent
to his successors
likewise seeking
for the gems that poet sent,
spending again what is already spent.
How can we be original
when so much is already written;
how turn a mundane thought
with skill into a verse of beauty;
without unconscious copying?
How dare we be so bold
to ape the bard,
without his genius,
outshining us tenfold?
As the sun is daily new and old
perhaps time changed the import
of the earlier words
to new significance
within the context of our modern world.
Perhaps on supplication
the bard may not withhold
consent for us to try
to write a worthwhile sonnet
which will shine anew as gold.
So is my love still telling what is told?
Given the time constraints of the challenge, and being out for a birthday lunch for Jock, this is inevitably a crude draft. But I enjoyed the form, and shall work on it again later.
At Hannah’s suggestion, I’m linking this at With Real Toads Open Link , and would be glad of any suggestions for improvement. Also linked at dVerse Poets’ pub, where you will find lots of lovely poetry.
you have me hoist with my own petard – I had better look at the tools of the poetic trade 🙂
LikeLike
This is quite a form and you succeeded, Viv. I suppose we do recycle the same truths in so many images. That’s part of the joy of poetry.
LikeLike
I agree with Brian: “All has not been said–all has not been read.” Somehow, poets & writers in the billions scour the same landscape, and unique creatures that we are, we can still find our own truth, our own turn of a phrase, metaphor, insight, time after time after time. I do enjoy attempting the classic poetic forms, but I could see in Tony Maude’s last prompt at dVerse, about rhythm & blank verse, some of us just see the world, and interpret it poetically; bless us every one.
LikeLike
amen
LikeLike
there is definitely much to be learned from form, from other poets (old and new)… your selection for the cabeza is quite perfect given the form you’re using. I enjoyed this piece.
LikeLike
Perhaps we can’t write something perfect in form and meter and idea; but that should never stop us from expressing our thoughts in our own way. How frustrating it would be for me if I waited for such perfection. My blog would be blank. (smiles)
LikeLike
This is something I think about often, and I am constantly amazed at how we can keep dressing old words new, given how many of us there are on this planet. It’s fascinating.
LikeLike
i was wondering the same questions just yesterday. i think with any art form, there is the tendency to feel that way. but as many have said, there is so much more to be said and so many new ways in which to say it. loved this.
LikeLike
Stretch your skill, and the words shall fill
LikeLike
A crude draft??? This is lovely! I have tried the Glosa twice, and love the challenge of the format. You have done this very well indeed!
LikeLike
How can we be original
when so much is already written..? that is a good question… it’s the same with music… i mean there are just so few tunes and millions and millions of different pieces of music and different styles… it’s amazing..isn’t it… so i think we have still loads of new space to discover…smiles
LikeLike
Wonderful. And yet another poetic form to get my brain cells around… One day! 🙂
LikeLike
Have a go – it is a very satisfying form and not as difficult as it sounds. Thanks for your visit.
LikeLike
I came to this glosa second (after your lovely glosa with the cabeza from Page’s “Planet Earth”) and this one has the amazing wry humor that I’ve come to know and love from you. And an ars poetica, you know I can’t resist these. Beautifully done!
LikeLike
An excellent response to the challenge – I do not think the Bard would mind a bit!
Anna :o]
LikeLike
This is an amazing statement of desire to write, fully knowing our limitations. Beautifully spoken.
LikeLike
Well done… these are questions often asked… never answered… and we keep writing just the same.
I love your use of the form.
LikeLike
you got a nice rhythm going on viv….there is plenty new to write…all has not been said, and if so not all has been read, so a new spin might be worth it…then again if two look at the same thing is not the perspective yet different?
LikeLike
smiles…been a bit…i still think there is room for it to be said still…still things to be found in the pen…the cool thing with the glosa is you get to join in with one of the greats eh? smiles..look forward to your new glosa viv…
LikeLike
third time is a charm…you know i was writing poetry a good 6 months to a year before i read it…and i still could not write an iamb if my life depended on it…still though, i agree that study/reading it all plays into craft…i think we have to make sure we keep our own voice and not adapt to those we read…but we can learn a trick and find new things to say in our own way…when we hold onto that…
LikeLike
Thanks Brian,
I agree. Variety is the spice and all that.
LikeLike
You rose up to the challenge well… and with Shakespeare, too! Mine was after Maya Angelou… I only posted it on Poetic Asides, though.
LikeLike
Wow–this is wonderful. I had trouble even understanding the description of the glosa! I sometimes wonder how these forms get established. But this is lovely. Write on!
LikeLike
Again, wonderful. Very well done. Filling with beauty turned askew– I know, I’m not phrasing properly. Lovely. K.
LikeLike
Crude? I say not…this is wonderful!
LikeLike
Viv, this is “crude”? Well, I’m “screwed”!
I understand your nods to the Bard, but truly, you have that music inside you, it spills out on the page and delights. I think Will would be mighty proud to have this piece associated with his work. Peace, Amy
LikeLike
“For as the sun is daily new and old,
So is my love still telling what is told.”
And that is exactly what poetry is about!
LikeLike
I love the tone and the form…it seems the poem itself is musings about musing. And as usual, I learned some new things just by visiting your site!
LikeLike
Crude? Not at all! I loved the following:
How dare we be so bold
to ape the bard,
without his genius,
outshining us tenfold?”
I think you did yourself proud and in such a short time! I think this is a lovely form that you should do again.
LikeLike
Enjoyed this very much. Ah, I wonder as well sometimes how one can write something original when so much has been written already! But I do think that the Bard would find this piece worthy!
LikeLike
Bless you for that, Mary.
LikeLike
Viv, I LOVE how you incorporated the Bard’s lines so seamlessly into your poem. You have expressed this beautifully and I dont think you need do one thing to it. I loved every line!
LikeLike
Well done Viv, I’m sure even the Bard himself would be smiling if he could read this.
LikeLike
This is a new form to me and I love reading it through your poem. You apply Shakespeare to himself here–such a borrower he was, and in his sonnets to his many loves he always tends to praise his own poetry instead–and so you do here in this marvelous mobius strip of a poem about poetry. So clever and accessible at the same time that I wish I had written it myself! Thank you for bringing this to the Garden.
LikeLike
Wow, that’s the highest compliment you could give me.
LikeLike
I had been rolling along with the challenge just fine, until this prompt. I don’t want admit defeat, but with 3 young children and a home to care for — a glosa cannot be built in a day! ha
but this is fantastic….although if this is “crude” I am really in trouble. thanks for showing how it’s done!
LikeLike
Get stuck in, Rorybore: once I started, it tumbled out joyfully in one go. To make sure the rhymes were in the right places, I wrote the numbers on each line,- 6, 9, 10, with the borrowed line written in at 10 a,. I kept http://www.b-rhymes.com/ open at the same time, to find the rhymes, and it practically wrote itself!
LikeLike
This was my procedure as well, Viv, except I use RhymeBrain. 😉
I LOVE your glosa. I especially love how you turned Shake’s last line into a question. Perfect.
I found this form challenging, and rewarding, also. Mine’s here, if you’re interested:http://whimsygizmo.wordpress.com/2012/11/18/divining-rod/
LikeLike
Coming right over.
LikeLike
Thanks so much for taking the time to stop by, and for your kind comment. I’m with Rorybore…if this was your “crude draft,” GOODNESS. 😉 Fantastic.
LikeLike
I had 4 lines from the best to start me off. There have been a couple of little tweaks during the day!
LikeLike
Well done, Viv. I particularly like “so all my best is dressing old words new” — so true, I find.
K
LikeLike
I have never heard of this form, Viv, this is quite beautiful.
Pamela
LikeLike
This has magic in it’s rhythm. After reading it, I hesitate to call what I am writing poetry! I do immerse myself in reading poetry – the masters and the modern . And get great joy from that. Thanks for sharing this.
LikeLike
Of course you are writing poetry! Just because I like writing to form, that doesn’t mean that other kinds of poetry aren’t equally valuable.
LikeLike
well done Viv, really! I hope that you will consider sharing an offering for this year’s 4th annual gratitude word quilt. You can find information about the project and how to participate at the top of my blog. If you’ve already sent something thank you and please forgive my poor memory. The quilt is growing quite expansive and with only first names, I can’t always remember who already shared. Feel free to write in your native language google translate is available on my blog so every one can read and understand one another. Every Blessing~ Laura
LikeLike
Beware Google translate: it can result in some hilarious bloopers.
LikeLike
“Read and read
until you’re filled
with beauty turned askew”
I love this, Viv!!!
You really worked the lines you chose well…each choice you made in the stanza preceding the borrowed lines not only support them but enhance them beautifully!!! So happy that this was my first read this A.M.!
On another note…your explanation of the form goes into greater detail than the one onsite at PAD …for example I don’t think I saw the part about the quatrain we borrowed being the opening . I don’t think you’ll mind if I add your opening explanation to my post for this form…? I’m going to go ahead and make those changes.
I was happy with the outcome for this one and since commenting @ PAD and Fb are limited I thought I’d link this poem to the Real Toads open link…maybe you could put your’s there as well to gather some more feedback.
Smiles to you this chilly Monday morning!!
LikeLike
Thank you, Hannah. I had a ball writing this, and yes, I did a bit of research on Glosa poems before starting. Of course you may use my intro.
LikeLike
Thank you so much, Viv!! I’ve added it and the clarity is…well, so much clearer! 😉
LikeLike
Well done, Viv! A gorgeous piece of work. The second stanza is my favourite.
LikeLike
Thank you Misky, it’s mine as well. I really enjoyed this prompt.
LikeLike
Sent you an email.
LikeLike
Thanks, Tilly. Suggested alterations made.
LikeLike
Viv, yes I remember the glosa challenge.. And the thoughts when old meets new can generate new thoughts. I think the famous writers block can lie in that the more we read the more we understand that we are but trying to recreate what’s already done.
LikeLike
I think you’re right.
LikeLike
So flowing and so organic, music to my mind and ears.:)
LikeLike